1899 – 1904 Percival Hickman Vicar
1903 – 1904 J. M. Graf
1904 – 1924 Thornton B. Rennell Vicar (Cousin of Mary Neosha Williams)
1924 – 1926 William Scranton Leete Vicar
1926 – 1927 Gustav A.C. Lehman Vicar
1927 – 1930 William Dwight Nutting Vicar
1930 – 1935 William Baker Vicar
1935 Charles Winfred Douglas Canon
1935 – 1937 Edwin J. Anderson Vicar
1937 W. Malcolm Notililins Curate
1937 – 1943 Charles Winfred Douglas Canon/Vicar
1943 – 1964 Bud Marsh Vicar/Rector
1964 – 1985 Charles H. Blakeslee Rector
1985 – 1988 Robert Bryan Rector
1988 Robert Royster Interim
1989 – 1997 Jack Stapleton Rector
William M. MacMillan Associate Rector
1997 Gary Goldacker Interim Pastor
1998 – 2009 Catherine Tran Rector
2009 – 2010 Bob Davidson Supply Priest
2010 – 2013 Mark Norris Priest-in-Charge
2013 Lada Hardwick Supply Priest
2014 Louis Blanchard Supply Priest
2014 Sarah Berlin Supply Priest
2014 – 2021 Michael McManus Rector
2022 George Berlin Interim Priest-in-Charge